Compliance Cases Made Public
For Immediate Release: Contact: Kelly Huff September 26, 2000 Ron Harris Sharon Snyder Ian StirtonCOMPLIANCE CASES MADE PUBLIC
WASHINGTON -- The Federal Election Commission has recently made public its final action on 36 matters previously under review (MURs). This release contains only summary information. Closed files should be thoroughly read for details, including the FEC’s legal analysis of the case. (See footnote at the end of this release.) Closed MUR files are available in the Public Records Office.
1. MUR 4748
RESPONDENTS: (a) WPXI, Inc. (WPXI-TV Channel 11) (PA)
blockquote blockquote(b) Pamela Spagnol, WPXI News Department Business Manager (PA)
(c) Carrie Moniot, WPXI Executive Producer, Special Projects Unit (PA)
(d) Robert Morford, former WPXI News Director (PA)
<lockquote> <lockquote>COMPLAINANTS: Judith Corley, Counsel for Citizens for Ron Klink (PA)
SUBJECT: Corporate contributions/contributions in the names of others
DISPOSITION: Conciliation Agreement: $1,000 civil penalty*
2. MUR 4759
RESPONDENTS: (a) Phillip J. Maloof (NM)
blockquote blockquote(b) Friends of Phil Maloof, Dolores Gonzales, treasurer (NM)
(c) Supporters of Phil Maloof, Theresa Keaveny, treasurer (NM)
<lockquote> <lockquote>COMPLAINANTS: Republican Party of New Mexico, John Dendahl, Chairman (NM)
SUBJECT: Disclaimers; failure to file Statement of Candidacy timely
DISPOSITION: Conciliation Agreement: $ 7,500 civil penalty*
3. MUR 4780
RESPONDENTS: (a) Harris Corporation (FL)
blockquote blockquote blockquote(b) Jeffrey Stanley (AK)
<lockquote> <lockquote> <lockquote>COMPLAINANT: Kimberly Blom (AK)
SUBJECT: Contribution by government contractor
DISPOSITION: (a-b) No reason to believe*
4. MUR 4808
RESPONDENTS: (a) Miles S. Rapoport (CT)
blockquote blockquote blockquote(b) Rapoport for the First, Barbara Wiggins, treasurer (CT)
(c) Connecticut AFL-CIO and Labor 98 (CT)
<lockquote> <lockquote> <lockquote>COMPLAINANTS: John B. Larson and Larson for Congress (CT)
SUBJECT: Independent expenditures; use of union funds; failure to report contributions
DISPOSITION: (a-c) No reason to believe*
5./6. MURs 4830 and 4845
RESPONDENTS: (a) Udall For Us All Committee, Carolyn H. Gonzales,
treasurer (NM) [4830/4845]
blockquote blockquote blockquote(b) Honorable Tom Udall (NM) [4830/4845]
blockquote (c) South Bay Voter Registration PAC, Sue Burnside, <lockquote> <lockquote> <lockquote> <lockquote>treasurer (NM) [4830/4845]
(d) Jill Z. Cooper (NM)
(e) Arlene Bergman (NC) (f) Barrie Bergman (NC)
(g) Yogi Bhajan (NM) (h) Curtis Boyd (NM)
(i) Winiford Carlile (NM) (j) Jessica Catto (NM)
(k) John Clark (NM) (l) Rosamaria Clark (NM)
(m) Marjorie Engel (NM) (n) Suzanne Fisher (NY)
(o) Thomas Dee Frasier (OK) (p) Daniel Haft (NM)
(q) Philip Hertzman (NM) (r) Thomas Keesing (NM)
(s) Jerome Kessler (NM) (t) Helen Kornblum (MO)
(u) Allan Kurtzman (CA) (v) Robert Mang (NM)
(w) Robert Martinez (DC) (x) Marsha Mason (NM)
(y) Susan McGreevy (NM) (z) Joyce Melander-Dayton (NM)
(aa) New Democratic Network, Simon Rosenberg, treasurer (DC)
(bb) Transportation Political Education League, Roger D.
Griffeth, treasurer (OH)
(cc) Edith Pierpont (NM) (dd) Rudolph Rasin (IL)
(ee) Marie Ridder (VA) (ff) Neil Rolde (ME)
(gg) Michael Rosenberg (NM) (hh) Donald Salazar (NM)
(ii) Jane L. Schrieber (NM) (jj) Carl Sheppard (NM)
(kk) Susan Simons (NM) (ll) Philip Smith (NM)
(mm) Jay Stein (NM) (nn) Dr. Edward Steinberg (FL)
(oo) Michael Traynor (CA) (pp) Lee Udall (NM)
(qq) Stewart Udall (NM) (rr) John Wirth (NM)
(ss) Stuart Woods (CT) (tt) Charles Zemach (NM)
(uu) American Federation of State, County, Municipal Employees (AFSCME) PAC, William Lucy, treasurer (DC)
(vv) Democratic Republican Independent Voter Education Committee (DRIVE), Tom Server, treasurer (DC)
(ww) International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers Committee on Political Education (IBEW-COPE), Edwin D. Hill, treasurer (DC)
(xx) George Coleman (NM) (yy) Valerie J. Fairchild (NM)
(zz) Brook Glaefke (MN) (ab) Don Henley (CA)
(ac) Sharon Henley (CA) (ad) Jacqueline Hoefer (NM)
(ae) William Kilgarlin (NM) (af) Marion Noel (TX)
(ag) Wendy Rockefeller (NY) (ah) Lynn Udall (NM)
(ai) Georgia Webster (TX)
COMPLAINANTS: Republican Party of New Mexico, John Dendahl, Chairman (NM)
SUBJECT: Accepted post-primary contributions for the primary election in excess of net debt outstanding; excessive contributions; use of prohibited funds; failure to properly report loan; failure to record other contributions it received
DISPOSITION: (a) Conciliation Agreement: $ 6,000 civil penalty*
(re: accepted post-primary contributions for the primary election in excess of net debt outstanding; excessive contributions; use of prohibited funds; failure to properly report loan; failure to record other contributions it received)
(a - b) Failed to find reason to believe*
(re: corporate contributions)
(c) Reason to believe, but took no further action*
(re: excessive contribution, prohibited contributions)
(d) No reason to believe*
(re: excessive contributions)
(e-tt) No reason to believe*
(uu-ai) Took no action*
7. MUR 4903
RESPONDENTS: Dallas Entrepreneurial Political Action Committee, Randall Goss, treasurer (DALENPAC) (TX)
COMPLAINANT: FEC Initiated (RAD)
SUBJECT: Failure to file disclosure report timely
DISPOSITION: Conciliation Agreement: $ 1,200 civil penalty*
8. MUR 4920
RESPONDENTS: Kind for Congress Committee, Mary JoAnn Werner, treasurer (WI)
COMPLAINANT: Gary L. Arneson (WI)
SUBJECT: Disclaimer
DISPOSITION: Reason to believe, but took no further action*
Sent admonishment letter.
9. MUR 4941
RESPONDENTS: Friends for Harry Reid, Clifford R. Beadle, treasurer (NV)
COMPLAINANT: FEC Initiated (RAD)
SUBJECT: Failure to file 48-hour report (candidate loan totalling $100,000)
DISPOSITION: Conciliation Agreement: $ 12,500 civil penalty*
10. MUR 4946
RESPONDENTS: (a) CBS News (NY)
blockquote blockquote blockquote(b) Fox News (NY)
(c) CNBC News (NJ)
(d) NBC News (NY)
(e) MSNBC News (DE)
(f) CNN (GA)
(g) ABC News (NY)
<lockquote> <lockquote> <lockquote>COMPLAINANT: Robert Vinson Brannum (DC)
SUBJECT: Corporate contributions (in the form of biased news coverage and commentary); denied access to federal candidates
DISPOSITION: (a-g) No reason to believe*
11. MUR 4968
RESPONDENTS: (a) Perot ’96, J. Michael Poss, treasurer (TX)
blockquote blockquote blockquote(b) Reform Party of the United States of America, Michael B. Morris, Jr., treasurer (TX)
(c) Russell Verney, Chairman, Reform Party of the United States of America (TX)
<lockquote> <lockquote> <lockquote>COMPLAINANTS: Mary Clare and William T. Wohlford (VA)
SUBJECT: Improper winding down expenditures; volunteer services
DISPOSITION: (a-c) No reason to believe*
[re: any provision of the Act]
12. MUR 4987
RESPONDENTS: (a) Commission on Presidential Debates (DC)
blockquote blockquote blockquote(b) Paul G. Kirk, Jr., Co-Chairman, Commission on Presidential
Debates (DC)
(c) Frank J. Fahrenkopf, Jr., Co-Chairman, Commission on Presidential Debates (DC)
(d) Republican National Committee - RNC, Alec Poitevint, treasurer (DC)
(e) DNC Services Corporation/Democratic National Committee, Andres Tobias, treasurer (DC)
<lockquote> <lockquote> <lockquote>COMPLAINANTS: Reform Party of the USA (AZ)
blockquote blockquote blockquotePat Choate, Chairman, Reform Party (AZ)
Patrick J. Buchanan (VA)
Buchanan Reform (VA)
Angela Buchanan (VA)
<lockquote> <lockquote> <lockquote>SUBJECT: Failure to register and report; corporate contributions
DISPOSITION: (a-c) No reason to believe*
[re: failure to register and report; corporate contributions]
(d-e) No reason to believe*
[re: failure to report contributions; corporate contributions]
13. MUR 4989
RESPONDENTS: (a) Dole for President Committee, Robert J. Dole, treasurer (DC)
blockquote blockquote blockquote(b) Dole/Kemp ’96 Inc., Robert J. Dole, treasurer (DC)
(c) US Airways, Inc. (VA)
<lockquote> <lockquote> <lockquote>COMPLAINANT: FEC Initiated (Audit)
SUBJECT: Corporate contributions (extension of credit outside ordinary
course of business)
DISPOSITION: (a-c) No reason to believe*
14. MUR 4996
RESPONDENTS: Pakistani American Physicians Public Affairs Committee, Dr. Parvez Shah, treasurer (NY)
COMPLAINANT: FEC Initiated (RAD)
SUBJECT: Failure to amend Statement of Organization timely; failure to file disclosure report timely
DISPOSITION: Conciliation Agreement: $ 5,500 civil penalty*
[Committee knowing and willfully failed to file 1998, 30 Day Post- General Report timely. Respondents agree to file amendments to all reports filed in 1999 and 2000 to reflect the Committee’s correct
cash-on-hand.]
15. MUR 4997
RESPONDENTS: National Cotton Council Committee for the Advancement of Cotton, William R. Tracy, treasurer (TN)
COMPLAINANT: FEC Initiated (RAD)
SUBJECT: Failure to file disclosure report timely
DISPOSITION: Conciliation Agreement: $ 1,050 civil penalty*
16. MUR 5002
RESPONDENTS: Brotherhood of Railroad Signalmen Political Action Committee, Walt A. Barrows, treasurer (IL)
COMPLAINANT: FEC Initiated (RAD)
SUBJECT: Failure to file disclosure reports timely
DISPOSITION: Conciliation Agreement: $ 1,800 civil penalty*
17. MUR 5004
RESPONDENTS: (a) Commission on Presidential Debates (DC)
blockquote blockquote blockquote(b) Paul G. Kirk, Jr., Co-Chairman, Commission on Presidential
Debates (DC)
(c) Frank J. Fahrenkopf, Jr., Co-Chairman, Commission on Presidential Debates (DC)
(d) Republican National Committee - RNC, Alec Poitevint, treasurer (DC)
(e) DNC Services Corporation/Democratic National Committee, Andrew Tobias, treasurer (DC)
<lockquote> <lockquote> <lockquote>COMPLAINANTS: Natural Law Party of the United States ("NLP") (IA)
John Hagelin (IA)
John Moore (IA)
SUBJECT: Failure to register and report; corporate contributions
DISPOSITION: (a-c) No reason to believe*
[re: failure to register and report; corporate contributions]
(d-e) No reason to believe*
[re: failure to report contributions; corporate contributions]
18. MUR 5008
RESPONDENTS: People for Patty Murray - U.S. Senate Campaign, C. Brandon Hall, treasurer (WA)
COMPLAINANT: FEC Initiated (RAD)
SUBJECT: Failure to file or timely file 48-hour reports
DISPOSITION: Conciliation Agreement: $ 6,400 civil penalty*
19. MUR 5009
RESPONDENTS: Sonoma County Republican Central Committee, Robert A. Matthews, treasurer (CA)
COMPLAINANT: FEC Initiated (RAD)
SUBJECT: Failure to file disclosure reports timely
DISPOSITION: Conciliation Agreement: $ 3,100 civil penalty*
20. MUR 5021
RESPONDENTS: (a) Commission on Presidential Debates (DC)
blockquote blockquote blockquote(b) Paul G. Kirk, Jr., Co-Chairman, Commission on Presidential
Debates (DC)
(c) Frank J. Fahrenkopf, Jr., Co-Chairman, Commission Presidential Debates (DC)
<lockquote> <lockquote> <lockquote>COMPLAINANT: Mary Clare Wohlford and William T. Wohlford (VA)
SUBJECT: Failure to use pre-established objective criteria for selection of candidates for participation in debates
DISPOSITION: (a-c) No reason to believe*
[re: failure to register and report; corporate contributions]
21. MUR 5047
RESPONDENTS: (a) Clinton/Gore ’96 General Committee, Inc., Joan Pollitt, treasurer (DC)
blockquote blockquote blockquote(b) World Wide Travel Services, Inc. (AR)
(c) M.S. Green - Little Rock Corporation d/b/a the Excelsior Hotel (AR)
(d) AT&T Corporation (DE)
<lockquote> <lockquote> <lockquote>COMPLAINANT: FEC Initiated (Audit)
SUBJECT: Corporate contributions (in the form of extensions of credit)
DISPOSITION: (a-c) Reason to believe, but took no further action*
(a & d) No reason to believe* [re: extension of credit from AT&T]
22. MUR 5051
RESPONDENTS: Democratic National Committee, Andrew Tobias, treasurer (DC)
[re: Victory ’96 Joint Fundraising project of the DNC and Clinton/Gore ’96 General Election Legal and Compliance Fund]
COMPLAINANT: FEC Initiated (Audit)
SUBJECT: Failure to report contributor’s occupation and names of employers
DISPOSITION: Reason to believe, but took no further action*
23. MUR 5052
RESPONDENTS: (a) Mid-America Conservative Political Action Committee (MACPAC), Les Borsay, treasurer (IA)
blockquote blockquote blockquote(b) Corey for Senate, Leroy Corey, treasurer (IA)
<lockquote> <lockquote> <lockquote>COMPLAINANT: FEC Initiated (Audit)
SUBJECT: Failure to report receipts and disbursements; failure to maintain records; misstatement of financial activity; excessive contributions; excessive cash disbursements
DISPOSITION: (a) Reason to believe, but took no further action*
[re: failure to report receipts and disbursements; failure to maintain records; misstatement of financial activity; excessive contributions; excessive cash disbursements ]
(b) Reason to believe, but took no further action*
[re: excessive contributions; failure to report contributions]
24. MUR 5055
RESPONDENTS: McCormick for Congress, Joseph F. McCormick, treasurer (GA)
COMPLAINANT: FEC Initiated (Audit)
SUBJECT: Excessive contributions
DISPOSITION: Reason to believe, but took no further action*
Instructed to take corrective action.
The Enforcement Priority System (EPS) rates all incoming cases against objective criteria to determine whether they warrant use of the Commission’s limited resources.
Cases dismissed under EPS fall into two categories: low-rated cases and stale cases. Low rated cases are those that do not warrant use of the Commission’s resources to pursue because of their lower significance relative to other pending matters. Stale cases are those that initially received a higher rating but have remained unassigned for a significant period due to a lack of staff resources for effective investigation. Effective enforcement relies upon the timely pursuit of complaints and referrals to ensure compliance with the law. Investigations concerning activity more remote in time usually require a greater commitment of resources, primarily due to the fact that the evidence of such activity becomes more difficult to develop as it ages. The utility of commencing an investigation declines as these cases age, until they reach a point when activation of a case would not be an efficient use of the Commission’s resources. As cases reach this point, they are recommended for dismissal.
Dismissed - Stale
25. Pre-MUR 369
RESPONDENTS:
(a) Christopher White, President and CEO, Mid-American Waste Systems, Inc. (OH) blockquote blockquote blockquote(b) Mid-American Waste Systems, Inc. (MAWS) (OH)
<lockquote> <lockquote> <lockquote>COMPLAINANT: Referral by Jon E. DeGuilio, Esq., United States Attorney, U.S. Department of Justice (IN)
SUBJECT: Corporate contributions/contributions in the names of others
DISPOSITION: (a-b) Declined to open MUR*
26. MUR 4721
RESPONDENTS: (a) Didrickson for US Senate, Lynn Didrickson, treasurer (IL)
blockquote blockquote blockquote(b) Chicago Sightseeing Co., Inc., Don Ferrone, President (IL)
<lockquote> <lockquote> <lockquote>COMPLAINANT: Michael R. Cys (IL)
SUBJECT: Failure to disclose disbursements; corporate contributions
DISPOSITION: Reason to believe/Took no further action*
27. MUR 4779
RESPONDENTS: (a) Honorable Robert L. Ehrlich, Jr., (MD)
blockquote blockquote blockquote(b) Ehrlich for Congress Committee, Henry A. Grandizio, treasurer (MD)
(c) Towson University (MD)
<lockquote> <lockquote> <lockquote>COMPLAINANT: Myles B. Hoenig (MD)
SUBJECT: Disclaimer
28. MUR 4795
RESPONDENTS: (a) Larry Pressler (SD)
blockquote blockquote blockquote(b) Friends of Larry Pressler, Daniel A. Nelson, treasurer (SD)
(c) David and Christina Yeh (CA)
(d) Tay K. Tin (CA)
(e) Angus Setiawan (CA)
(f) Susan Henes-Dequeljoe (CA)
(g) Charles L. Dequeljoe (CA)
(h) Joseph and Hylen Sund (NY)
(i) Felix and Mary Ma (CA)
<lockquote> <lockquote> <lockquote>COMPLAINANT: Roger Andal (SD)
SUBJECT: Use of campaign funds for personal use; failure to accurately report disbursements
29. MUR 4810
RESPONDENTS: (a) Independence Party of New York, Tom Galisano, treasurer (NY)
blockquote blockquote blockquote(b) Friends of John LaFalce, Theresa F. Opalinski, treasurer (NY)
<lockquote> <lockquote> <lockquote>COMPLAINANT: Ralph M. Mohr (NY)
SUBJECT: Failure to register and report; excessive contributions; disclaimer; failure to file 48-hour reports
30. MUR 4820
RESPONDENTS: (a) Honorable Helen P. Chenoweth (ID)
blockquote blockquote blockquote(b) Chenoweth for Congress Committee, Richard W. Jackson,
treasurer (ID)
(c) Republican National Committee, Alec Poitevint, treasurer (DC)
(d) National Republican Congressional Committee, Donna M. Anderson, treasurer (DC)
(e) Idaho Republican Party Federal Campaign Account, Cheryl Miller, treasurer (ID)
<lockquote> <lockquote> <lockquote>COMPLAINANTS: W. Anthony Park, State Chair, Idaho State Democratic Party (ID)
SUBJECT: Issue ads
31. MUR 4839
RESPONDENTS: (a) Charles A. (Chuck) Pierce (MO)
blockquote blockquote blockquote(b) Pierce for Auditor, Marc. H. Ellinger, treasurer (MO)
(c) William J. Federer (MO)
(d) Federer for Congress Committee, Thomas M. Busken, treasurer (MO)
(e) Honorable Kenny C. Hulshof (MO)
(f) Hulshof for Congress, John E. Becker, Sr., treasurer (MO)
(g) KSDK - TV (Channel 5, NBC) (MO)
<lockquote> <lockquote> <lockquote>COMPLAINANTS: Judith L. Corley, Counsel, Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee (DC) and Missouri Democratic Party (MO)
SUBJECT: Use of non-federal funds in connection with federal elections; excessive contributions
32. MUR 4841
RESPONDENTS: (a) Honorable Richard H. Baker (LA)
blockquote blockquote blockquote(b) Baker for Congress Committee, Alvin J. Ourso, Jr., treasurer (LA)
(c) Baker Agency, Richard Baker, Owner (LA)
(d) Kay Baker and K’s Louisiana Market, Kay Baker, Owner (LA)
(e) Christine Casteel, Owner, Tricolor Group (LA)
(f) Durwood Casteel (LA)
<lockquote> <lockquote> <lockquote>COMPLAINANTS: Louisiana Democratic Party, Ben Jeffers, Chairman (LA)
SUBJECT: Use of campaign funds for personal use; failure to accurately report disbursements; excessive contributions
33. MUR 4855
RESPONDENTS: (a) Michael Burkhold (SC)
blockquote blockquote blockquote(b) Committee to Elect Mike Burkhold to Congress, Hulic Ratterree, treasurer (SC)
(c) Zeus Mediterranean Foods and Michael B. Burkhold, Jr., President - Managing Member (SC)
<lockquote> <lockquote> <lockquote>COMPLAINANTS: Spratt for Congress Committee, John M. Spratt, Jr., Esq. (SC)
SUBJECT: Failure to provide contributor information and demonstrate "best efforts"; candidate loans from other than personal funds
34. MUR 4861
RESPONDENTS: (a) Matthew K. Fong (CA)
blockquote blockquote blockquote(b) Matt Fong US Senate Committee, William R. Turner, treasurer (CA)
(c) Pension and Benfits Insurance and Adam R. DeVone, Owner (CA)
<lockquote> <lockquote> <lockquote>COMPLAINANT: Michael A. Sedéy (CA)
SUBJECT: Contributions in the names of others
35. MUR 4865
RESPONDENTS: (a) The Mercury Group, Inc., Tony Makris, Executive Director (VA)
blockquote blockquote blockquote(b) Ackerman McQueen, Inc. (OK)
(c) National Rifle Association (NRA), Wayne LaPierre, Executive
Director (VA)
(d) Arena Political Action Committee (ARENA PAC), Barbara W. Bonfiglio, treasurer (DC)
<lockquote> <lockquote> <lockquote>COMPLAINANT: Weldon H. Clark, Jr. (SC)
SUBJECT: Use of improper funds for federal elections; other matters not within FEC jurisdiction
36. MUR 4880
RESPONDENTS: (a) Tom Pigeon (CA)
blockquote blockquote blockquote(b) Shirlee Pigeon (CA)
(c) Word Mill Publishing Company (CA)
(d) The Inland Empire Conservative Coalition (CA)
(e) The Conservative Voice (CA)
(f) Khoury for Congress Campaign Committee, Sally Ann Grossman, treasurer (CA)
(g) California Republican Assembly (CA)
(h) Ken Calvert for Congress, Varis C. Smith, treasurer (CA)
(i) Southern California Christian Times (CA)
(j) National Policy Council (DC)
(k) Arab American Institute (DC)
(l) Dr. James Zogby President, Arab American Institute (DC)
<lockquote> <lockquote> <lockquote>(m) American Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee and Hala Maksoud (DC)
COMPLAINANT: R. M. "Cook" Barela (CA)
SUBJECT: Numerous allegations
*There are four administrative stages to the FEC enforcement process:
1. Receipt of proper complaint 3. "Probable cause" stage
2. "Reason to believe" stage 4. Conciliation stage
It requires the votes of at least four of the six Commissioners to take any action. The FEC can close a case at any point after reviewing a complaint. If a violation is found and conciliation cannot be reached, then the FEC can institute a civil court action against a respondent.
# # #