FEC v. New York State Conservative Party State Committee/1984 Victory Fund (87-3309)
On April 17, 1990, the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York issued a final consent order and judgment declaring that the New York State Conservative Party State Committee/1984 Victory Fund made excessive contributions in connection with a 1982 direct mail project for Florence M. Sullivan, a Republican candidate in the 1982 Senatorial primary election in New York. (Civil Action No. 87-3309). The order included a $15,000 civil penalty.
The consent order stated that the defendants first made a $4,980 in-kind contribution to the Sullivan for Senate Committee by paying for the printing of direct mail literature. Subsequently, the defendants allowed the Sullivan Committee to use the Victory Fund's nonprofit postal permit, saving the Sullivan committee $24,852.15 on postage (i.e., the difference between the usual bulk rate for the Sullivan letters and the postage actually paid using the nonprofit permit). These in-kind contributions exceeded the $5,000 per candidate, per election limit for multicandidate committees, set forth at 2 U.S.C. §441a(a)(2)(A).
In addition, the order stated that the Victory Fund failed to report the in-kind contribution of the postage costs, in violation of 2 U.S.C. §434(b).
The consent order required the Victory Fund to amend its reports and pay a $15,000 civil penalty. Finally, the defendants were permanently enjoined from future similar violations.
 Payment of the civil penalty in this consent order will also satisfy two prior outstanding default judgments in FEC v. 1984 Victory Fund (Civil Action Nos. 86-3891 and 85-8384). See the March 1987, June 1986 and December 1985 issues of the Record for more information on those suits.
Source: FEC Record — June 1990