MUR #4845

RESPONDENTS: Udall For Us All; American Federation of State County & Municipal Employees - P E O P L E; Bergman, Arlene; Bergman, Barrie; Bhajan, Yogi; Boyd, Curtis; Burnside, Susan; Carlile, Winford; Catto, Jessica; Clark, John; Clark, Rosamaria Ellis; Coleman, George E.; Cooper, Jill; Democratic Republican Independent Voter Education Committee; Engel, Marjorie Miller; Fairchild, Valerie Jean; Fisher, Suzanne; Frasier, Thomas Dee; Glaefke, Brook; Gonzales, Carolyn H.; Griffeth, Roger D.; Haft, Daniel; Henley , Donald H.; Henley, Sharon; Hertzman, Philip; Hill, Edwin D.; Hoefer, Jacqueline; International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers Local 98 Committee on Political Education; Keesing, Thomas; Kessler, Jerome; Kilgarlin, William W.; Kornblum, Helen; Kurtzmann, Allan; Mang, Robert; Martinez, Robert; Mason, Marsha; McGreevy, Susan; Melander-Dayton, Joyce; New Democrat Network; Noel, Marion; Pierpont, Edith; Rasin, Rudolph; Ridder, Marie; Rockefeller, Wendy; Rolde, Neil; Rosenberg, Michael; Rosenberg, Simon; Salazer, Donald; Schreiber, L. Jane; Sever, Tom; Sheppard, Carl; Simons, Susan; Smith, Phillip; South Bay Voter Registration; Stein, Jay; Steinberg, Edward L.; Traynor, Michael; Udall, Lee; Udall, Lynn; Udall, Steward; Udall, Tom; United Transportation Union (UTU), Transportation Political Education League; Webster, George; Wirth, John; Woods, Stuart; Zemach, Charles

COMPLAINANTS: Dendahl, John; Republican Party of New Mexico

SUBJECT: Contributions-Prohibited; Contributions-Excessive; Loans; Reporting

DISPOSITION: Decided by vote 6-0 to: (1) Accept the conciliation agreement submitted by the Udall For Us All Committee and Carolyn H. Gonzales, as treasurer, as recommend in the General Counsel Report #2 date April 10, 2000. ( 2) Close the file. (3) Approve the appropriate letters, as recommend in the General Counsel Report #2 date April 10, 2000.
Failed in vote 2-4 to pass a motion to: 1. Find RTB that the Udall For Us All Committee and Carolyn H. Gonzales, as treasurer, violated 2 U.S.C. 441b. 2. Find RTB that Tom Udall violated 2 U.S.C. 441b.
Decided by vote 6-0 to: 1. Find RTB that the Udall For Us All Committee and Carolyn H. Gonzales, as treasurer, violated 2 U.S.C. 434(b) and 441a(f). 2. Find RTB that the South Bay Voter Registration PAC and Susan Burnside, as treasurer, violated 2 U.S.C. 441a(a)(1)(A) and 441b, but take no further action and close the file as to this respondent. 3. Find no RTB that Jill Cooper violated 2 U.S.C. 441a(a)(1)(A) and close the file as to this respondent. 4. Find no RTB that Arlene Bergman, Barrie Bergman, Yogi Bhajan, Curtis Boyd, Winiford Carlile, Jessica Catto, John Clark, Rosemaria Clark, Marjorie Engel, Suzanne Fisher, Thomas Dee Frasier, Daniel Haft, Philip Hertzman, Thomas Keesing, Jerome Kessler, Helen Kornblum, Allan Kurtzman, Robert Mang, Robert Martinez, Marsha Mason, Susan McGreevy, Joyce Melander-Dayton, New Democratic Network and Simon Rosenberg, as treasurer, Edith Pierpont, Rudolph Rasin, Marie Ridder, Neil Rolde, Michael Rosenberg, Donald Salazar, Jane L. Schrieber, Carl Sheppard, Susan Simons, Philip Smith, Jay Stein, Dr. Edward Steinberg, Transportation Political Education League and Roger D. Griffeth, as treasurer, Michael Traynor, Lee Udall, Stewart Udall, John Wirth, Stuart Woods and Charles Zemach violated the Act with respect to this matter, and close the file as to these respondents. 5. Take no action with respect to the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees PAC, George Coleman, DRIVE Political Fund, Valerie Jean Fairchild, Brook Glaefke, Don Henley, Sharon Henley, Jacqueline Hoefer, International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers-COPE, William Kilgarlin, Marion Noel, Wendy Rockefeller, Lynn Udall and Georgia Webster, and close the file as to these respondents. 6. Enter into conciliation with the Udall For Us All Committee and Carolyn H. Gonzales, as treasurer, prior to a finding of PCTB. 7. Approve the Factual and Legal Analyses (2) and Conciliation Agreement attached to the First GC Report dated June 21, 1999. 8. Approve the appropriate letters.