FEC Seal

HOME / ABOUT THE FEC / COMMISSIONERS / FORMER COMMISSIONERS / COMMISSIONER SCOTT E. THOMAS / STATEMENTS AND OPINIONS

 

 

 

DISSENTING OPINION

 

OF

 

CHAIRMAN SCOTT E. THOMAS

COMMISSIONER DANNY LEE MCDONALD

 

ADVISORY OPINION 1999-28

 

In voting against Advisory Opinion 1999-28, we continue to believe that under 2 U.S.C. 441e, a wholly owned domestic subsidiary and its foreign national parent corporation should be treated as one entity. See, e.g., Dissents in Advisory Opinions 1989-29 and 1992-16 at [1976-1990 Transfer Binder] Fed. Elec. Camp. Fin. Guide (CCH) 5976, and 1 Fed. Elec. Camp. Fin. Guide (CCH) 6059, respectively; and Statement for the Record in Advisory Opinion Request 1996-6, 1 Fed. Elec. Camp. Fin. Guide (CCH) 6994. Section 441e broadly prohibits a foreign national (which includes a foreign corporation) from making a political contribution "through any other person." 2 U.S.C. 441e (emphasis added). Just as a domestic corporation and its subsidiaries are seen as one entity in order to prevent a parent corporation from making excessive contributions through its subsidiaries’ political committees (see, e.g., 2 U.S.C. 441a(a)(5); 2 U.S.C. 441b(b)(4)(A)(i); 11 C.F.R. 114.5(g)(1)), so too a foreign national parent corporation and its subsidiaries should be seen as one entity to prevent the foreign national corporation from making prohibited contributions through its subsidiaries.

Bacardi-Martini, USA, Inc. ("Bacardi") is the wholly owned subsidiary of Bacardi Limited, a Bermuda corporation and thus a "foreign principal" as defined by 22 U.S.C. 611(b). See 2 U.S.C. 441e(b)(1). As the wholly owned subsidiary of a foreign national corporation, Bacardi should not be allowed to make contributions to candidates for political offices in the United States.

 

11/19/99 / s /

________________________ _________________________________

Date Scott E. Thomas

Chairman

11/22/99 / s /

________________________ _________________________________

Date Danny Lee McDonald

Commissioner