CHAPTER 15
Termination and Debt
Settlement
1. Committees with No Outstanding Debts
A party committee may terminate its registration and reporting
obligations by filing a termination
report, provided that:
• The committee no longer intends to receive
contributions, make expenditures, or make any disbursements that would
otherwise qualify it as a political committee. 102.3(a)(1);
• Neither the committee seeking to terminate nor
any affiliated committee has any
outstanding debts or obligations (102.3); and
• The committee is not involved in an enforcement
action, an audit or litigation with the FEC.
Termination
Report
A
party committee that meets the above criteria may file a termination report at
any time. The treasurer must check the “Termination Report” box on Line 4 of
the Form 3X Summary Page.
The
termination report must disclose:
• All receipts and disbursements not previously
reported, including an accounting of debt retirement; and
• The purposes for which any remaining committee
funds will be used. 102.3(a).
A
party committee may use its remaining funds for any lawful purpose, including
refunding them to their donors or giving them to charity. AOs 1992-10 and
1991-21.
When
to Stop Reporting
The
committee’s reporting obligation ends when the Commission notifies the
committee in writing that the termination report has been accepted.
2. Committees with Outstanding Debts: Debt Settlement
Eligibility
for Debt Settlement
A
committee that has outstanding debts but wants to terminate may settle its
debts for less than the full amount owed to the creditors. This option is
available only to a terminating committee
—i.e., a committee which no longer intends to support candidates and which
receives contributions and makes expenditures only for the purpose of paying winding-down administrative
expenses (if any) and retiring debts.
116.1(a) and 116.2(a). (An ongoing
committee—i.e., a committee that does not qualify as a terminating
committee—is not eligible for debt settlement and must continuously report
debts until they are extinguished. 104.3(d), 116.1(b) and 116.2(b). However,
the committee may resolve their disputed debts or may request a Commission
determination that such debts are not payable. 116.10 and 116.9)
Debts
Subject to Settlement
The
types of debts that are subject to debt settlement requirements include:
• Amounts owed to commercial vendors;
• Debts arising from advances by individuals[1]
(e.g., staff using personal funds or
credit to purchase goods and services on behalf of the committee);
• Salary owed to committee employees; and
• Loans owed to political committees or individuals (including candidates).
116.7(b).
Debts
Not Subject to Settlement
The
debt settlement rules do not apply to:
• Disputed
debts, which are covered by other rules (see below). 116.7(c)(2) and 116.10.
• Bank loans. However, the Commission recognizes
that under extraordinary circumstances, such as the death or bankruptcy of the
candidate, settlement of bank loans may be appropriate. (The Commission will
consider specific requests on a case-by-case basis.)
Debt
Settlement Rules
A
commercial vendor (incorporated or unincorporated) may forgive or settle debts
owed by a committee without incurring a contribution if:
• Credit was initially extended in the ordinary
course of business, and the terms of the credit are similar to those observed
by the vendor when extending a similar amount of credit to a nonpolitical
client of similar risk and size of obligation. 116.3 and 116.4(d)(1);
• The committee undertook all reasonable efforts
to satisfy the outstanding debt, such as fundraising, reducing overhead costs
and liquidating assets. 116.4(d)(2); and
• The vendor made the same efforts to collect the
debt as those made to collect debts from a nonpolitical debtor in similar
circumstances. Remedies might include, for example, late fee charges, referral
to a debt collection agency or litigation. 116.4(d)(3). If the committee or the
creditor fails to take these steps, the difference between the amount owed and
the amount actually paid may be considered a contribution. 114.2(b).
Creditor’s
Rights
No
commercial vendor or other creditor is required to forgive or settle debts owed
by committees. 116.4(e).
Debt Settlement Plans
Once
a terminating committee has reached an agreement with a creditor, the treasurer
should file a debt settlement plan on FEC Form 8 (Examples:
Part I,
Part II and
Part III). Debt settlement plans must
include the signature of all creditors listed in Part I of Form 8. The
treasurer may use a separate form for each debt or may combine several debt
settlements in one plan.
Completing
Form 8
Step-by-step
instructions for completing Form 8 are included with the form. The treasurer
must sign and date the first page, Part I.
Commission
Review
The
Commission reviews each debt settlement plan to ensure compliance with the
rules discussed above and with the criteria listed in Commission regulations
116.7(f). After reviewing the plan, the Commission sends a written notification
to the committee.
Payment
to Creditors
The
committee must postpone paying the creditors included in a plan until the
Commission has completed its review. 116.7(a).
Reporting
Debts Undergoing Settlement
General
Rule
Debts
undergoing settlement must be continuously reported until the Commission has
completed its review of the committee’s debt settlement plan. The committee may
file a termination report once all debts have been paid, settled, forgiven or
otherwise extinguished. Payments to creditors should be disclosed on this
report. 116.4(f), 116.5(e) and 116.6(c).
Disputed
Debts
A
disputed debt is a bona fide disagreement between the creditor and the committee
as to the existence of a debt or the amount owed by the committee. 116.1(d). See
here for
information on how to report a disputed debt on Schedule D.
When
filing a debt settlement plan, a terminating committee must describe any
disputed debts and the committee’s efforts to resolve them on Part II of Form
8. 116.10. Disclosure of a disputed debt does not constitute an admission of
liability or a waiver of any claims the committee may have against the creditor.
116.10(a).
Unpayable
Debts
Both
terminating and ongoing committees may obtain a determination from the
Commission that a debt is unpayable for purposes of the Act because the creditor cannot be located or has gone out of
business. The committee must demonstrate that it made the necessary efforts to
locate the creditor and must continue to report the debt until the Commission
determines that the debt is unpayable. 116.9.
3. Committees with Outstanding Debts: Administrative Termination
An
inactive committee that wants to terminate but still has outstanding debts must
make efforts to settle the debts under the procedures described above. If debt
settlement efforts fail, however, such a committee may seek administrative
termination by the FEC. (The Commission may also, at its own initiative,
administratively terminate a committee’s reporting status.)
Criteria
for Administrative Termination
When
determining a committee’s eligibility for administrative termination, the
Commission will consider the following factors:
• The committee is not involved in any matter
before the Commission (such as a
• The committee’s aggregate reported financial
activity in one year is less than $5,000.
• The committee’s reports disclose no receipt of
contributions for the previous year.
• The committee’s last report disclosed minimal
expenditures.
• The committee’s primary purpose for filing its
reports has been to disclose outstanding debts and obligations.
• The committee has failed to file reports for
the previous year.
• The committee’s last report disclosed that the
debts owed to the committee were not substantial.
• The committee’s outstanding debts and
obligations do not appear to present a possible violation of the Act’s contribution prohibitions and
limitations.
• The committee’s outstanding debts and
obligations exceed the total of the committee’s reported cash-on-hand balance.
102.4(a) and FEC Directive
45.[2]
Procedures
for Requesting Administrative Termination
When
requesting administrative termination, the committee’s treasurer should set
forth the committee’s eligibility in writing, based on the factors listed
above. 102.4(b). In addition, with respect to any outstanding debts, the
committee’s request should describe:
• The terms and conditions of the initial
extension of credit;
• Steps taken by the committee to repay the debt;
and
• Efforts made by the creditors to obtain
payment.
Requests
should be addressed to the Commission’s Reports Analysis Division.
Once
the Commission completes its review of the request, the committee will be sent
a written notification of the Commission’s approval or disapproval. Committees
must continue to file regular reports until the request for administrative
termination has been approved. For more information, see FEC Directive 45.